Tag Archives: fall in love

What is wrong with me?

What Is Wrong With Me? Why did I have an affair? Am I broken?I have spoken with a lot of people who have had affairs.  Frequently these people get into a lot of study and searching, looking for an answer to some question like “Why did I have an affair?” or “What is broken about me, what is wrong with me, that I would have an affair?” or “What is wrong with me that I was looking for something else outside of my marriage?”

If you have had an affair, I can explain to you why you had the affair.  I have learned Dr. Harley’s take on the subject, and I have seen enough marriages with affairs to accept his position: people have affairs because we are all wired for it.  Having an affair is completely normal and natural.  It does not mean that you are broken and need to be fixed.

According to Dr. Harley, we would all have an affair under the right circumstances.  Many people dispute that, but from what I have seen, I believe it to be true.  We are all wired to fall in love and to reproduce.  Create the right circumstances for falling in love, and it will happen every time.

Maybe you think everybody else finds fidelity easy and natural.  Maybe you think they are “normal” and you are “broken.”  But the truth is, if we could take those people and put them in circumstances that cause them to fall in love with someone besides their spouse, they would suddenly find it almost impossible to be faithful.  And if we take you and make sure that you never get into circumstances where an affair could be possible, then no matter how enticing you have felt affairs were in the past, you would be completely faithful.

According to Dr. Harley, there are some circumstances under which all of us could be trusted – and some circumstances under which none of us should be trusted.  He’s right!

We are all wired to fall in love and to reproduceFeeling desire for someone you are not married to is not a sign that there is something wrong with you.  That is something completely normal and natural that happens to people who are close to someone of the opposite sex.  You should realize that if you act on that desire, you will hurt the person you have made a solemn vow to care for.  And you should also realize that if you remain in contact with the person you are feeling desire for, they will make Love Bank deposits in their account in your Love Bank, and your feelings for them will only increase.  That’s how everybody’s Love Bank works.  So if you find yourself attracted to somebody else, the thing to do is to 1) tell your spouse, and 2) break off all contact with the person you are feeling desire for, for life.

Dr. Harley realized early in life that nearly every member of his family had had an affair.  He realized that if he did not take extraordinary precautions to prevent an affair, he would end up being unfaithful to his wife Joyce.  Dr. Harley is at risk of an affair, just like you and me.  He is not broken, and neither are you.  He took those extraordinary precautions to make an affair impossible, and he has never had an affair.  He didn’t have to take those extraordinary precautions because he had something wrong with them: he had to do that because anybody who doesn’t is very likely to fall in love with someone else and have an affair.

By the way, if you have had an affair and are reading or getting therapy to find out what is “wrong” with you, or to “fix” yourself, you are taking a very selfish route while your victim (your spouse) is suffering.  You will never “fix” the thing inside you that leads to affairs, because it is a part of human wiring and we all have it.  But you can fix your mistake, and fix your marriage, by taking extraordinary precautions to prevent an affair, and meeting your spouse’s emotional needs and working to heal them from the hurt you have caused.

Are you listening to the Marriage Builders Radio show, daily?  Do you have the app?  Remember, Dr. Willard Harley is the expert – not me.  He’s the one who figured out how to save marriages.  I’m just happy to pass on what I have learned from his program and materials.  And the best advice I can give you is, take Dr. Harley’s free “class” on the radio every day!

Our top 5

As we begin a new year, here are our top 5 most visited posts in 2014: 

affair

affection2

conversation

plan

clockDid these blog posts help you? Do you have a marriage question they didn’t address? Email us, or post in the comments below! We would love to help you.

The problem is that your wife is not in love with you

She's not in love with you: How to pursue and win the heart of your wife

Image: Sander van der Wel, CC BY-SA 2.0 , via Wikimedia Commons

“I just don’t get it,” said Fred.  “Lisa doesn’t want to have sex with me at all.  When she does it’s only begrudgingly.  I could almost put up with that, but she doesn’t seem to want to be friends with me either.  She doesn’t want to talk to me or hear what I have to say.  She spends all of her time doing things I’m not interested in.  She never calls me during the day at work, and when I call her she wants to get off the phone as soon as possible.  And she won’t go out with me, either.

“I could almost handle the lack of sex if she would just have a relationship with me.  I am so incredibly lonely, and frustrated.  I have basically no friends at all, and she wants to be with anyone in the world besides me.  Her mother, sisters, friends, our kids – they all come before me.

“It wasn’t like this when we were dating.  Lisa couldn’t get enough conversation with me.  We talked on the phone every night until 1.  And we went out every chance we got and did so many fun things together.  She was a blast to be with, and there were stars in her eyes whenever she looked at me.  It seemed like she really liked me.  And when we first got married she was so eager to have sex all the time.  Now I wonder if it was all an act – was she just pretending, and she’s just not the kind of woman who wants to have a man in her life?  Did she just want to have children, and I was her way to get that?  Is all she wants out of marriage a paycheck and a babysitter?

“I have tried to get Lisa to go to a counselor.  I’ve tried all kinds of books and suggestions to get her interested in sex.  She’ll have none of it.  She dismisses my attempts to have a closer relationship, and shuts down every conversation I have with her as soon as possible.  If I bring her flowers and gifts she ignores them.

“I’m really starting to think that Lisa is just not that interested in marriage.  I think she’s just not that kind of person, and I should quit trying.”

Fred was in a situation many men find themselves in.  Frustrated and alone, with his emotional needs unmet, Fred can hardly be blamed for feeling despair.  But he probably doesn’t realize what the true problem in his marriage is.  Listening to the history of Fred’s marriage, and with a little bit of knowledge about the Love Bank, it is easy to see what happened, and how to fix it.

The main problem in Fred’s marriage is that his wife Lisa is no longer in love with him.  Look at how I can tell you for a fact that everything changes when your wife is in love with youher behavior changed.  When they were dating, and when they were first married, Fred’s balance in Lisa’s Love Bank was very high.  She was in love with him, and she wanted to be with him, and wanted to meet his emotional needs.  Over time, Fred did not continue to make enough Love Bank deposits, and probably made many withdrawals as well.  Lisa fell out of love with Fred, and her feelings toward him have probably become increasingly negative.  Her feelings of love probably turned to like and now have gotten pretty neutral.  Women don’t want to have sex with a man they feel neutral to, and they don’t really want to be his companion, either.  If things continue as they are, Lisa’s feelings toward Fred may eventually turn to dislike, and even to hatred.

There’s a good chance that after marriage, the problems that Fred and Lisa faced become more complicated, and the demands on their time became greater.  This happens to most couples.  Having children is one likely reason for increasingly complex problems and time demands.  To stay in love, or to tall back in love, Fred and Lisa need to make sure to spend enough time alone.  And they need to make sure that they resolve their problems in a way that they both feel happy about, without any Love Busters.

The truth is that Fred completely eliminates Love Busters, makes an all out effort to spend time with Lisa and learn to meet her emotional needs, and learns to look for win-win solutions to their problems, he can probably turn Lisa’s feelings for him around.  She can fall in love with him again, and once she is in love with him most of the problems Fred feels in their marriage will vanish, because she will probably want to have good times with him again and talk with him and have sex with him.  How do I know?  Because Fred’s story is markos’s story.  I could have written almost every word of Fred’s story a few years ago and it would have been about my own marriage.  I can tell you for a fact that everything changes when your wife is in love with you.

If you are in Fred’s situation, you are in the right place, because there is a plan you can follow to get your wife to fall in love with you again.  Stay with me and keep reading, and I’ll show you how to follow that plan.  Be sure and get the books you need to learn how to use the marriage recovery tools I write about here.  Read them and reread them.  And if you are having any trouble, post a comment here on the blog or send me an email at MarkosOnMarriage@gmail.com.  You can be anonymous; I will be happy to answer your questions.  I saved my marriage this way, and I have helped other people do the same, and I want to help you as well.

My Hosea

“Therefore I am now going to allure her; I will lead her into the wilderness and speak tenderly to her.” Hosea 2:14

guest bloggerThe book of Hosea is a bittersweet story of the love God has for his adulterous wife, Israel. And how he pursued her to win her back.

It has come to hold a special place in my heart.

My name is Prisca, and I am Markos’ wife. That sentence alone gives my heart a chill because, you see, my story is also bittersweet. When I first met Markos, I was easily swept off my feet. He was handsome beyond a dream and his deep, base voice stole my heart. And he was so easy to talk to — I would spend hours upon hours talking to him when we were together, and, when apart, dreaming about what I would I would say to him when I saw him once more.   I wanted him, to be held by him, to be loved by him. And what was even more perfect, he wanted me. He pursued me.

It was a fairy tale romance.

People would tell me that the love would one day fade, but I didn’t believe them. I was horrified that anybody would ever suggest such a thing to me — We were different. We weren’t just infatuated — we had a deep, romantic connection, and I just knew it would last forever.

As if cursed (the way fairy tales seem to always go), that love began to “fade” within the first year of our marriage. We started fighting. We neglected each other. We lived independent lifestyles. I can remember the first day Markos actually yelled at me — it tore a ragged hole in my fairy tale romance, and a small seed of hate was planted in the debris. I began to believe those naysayers from before our marriage. Love just didn’t last and I mourned this loss.

Markos started taking me to marriage counselors. He still believed that our love could be restored. I saw him as foolish, and hated being forced to tell my story to a complete stranger over and over again. We left each session, more bitter and torn apart than when we arrived.

Then Markos introduced me to Marriage Builders. He looked like an excited boy, fiMy Hosea: How he won me in spite of what I did to himnding a map that would lead him to the greatest treasure imaginable. I believe my first words to him were: “Yeah right, I’m not going to talk to some guy on the phone about sex!” He quietly started working the program on his own. I noticed a major change in him — and began to wonder if maybe he weren’t as big a jerk as I thought him to be.

He persuaded me to go the the Marriage Builders weekend in Minneapolis. The biggest selling point was that if I were to go to the sessions with him, he would take me shopping at the Mall of America. I didn’t relish the idea of sitting through anymore marriage sessions, but he knew how to entice me and I went. The sessions actually intrigued me for a change. And we spent the whole weekend having fun, like two teenagers dating each other for the first time. It was a breath of fresh air.

We learned about each others emotional needs (I so desperately wanted conversation), and the lovebusters that we believed would end our marriage if not dealt with (markos still had regular angry outbursts). For a while, I had hope.

But, back home, the fights continued. I continued to feel neglected. And his account in my lovebank dwindled deep down into the red. Six months after we went to the seminar, I was crying to him because he would not talk to me. In an angry outburst he said “Find somebody else to talk to!” That was it. The moment I first hated him. I hated him. I finally, really hated him.

I retreated from him. Dr. Harley calls this the state of withdrawal. I no longer cared for him. I no longer wanted him to meet my emotional needs for me. If he tried to, I only hated him more for the effort.

But I was terribly lonely. I turned to Facebook, of all things. I’m not the kind of person that has a whole lot of friends — I’m an introvert, and enjoy a small group of close friends. But on Facebook, I could be different. It was so much easier to be outgoing and chat with a variety of “friends.” Markos and I had just recently “joined” our accounts on Facebook, too, and so now my pool of friends to talk with had more than doubled. I started chatting with church members, and family, and Markos’ male friends.

Facebook started to consume my days. When I was happy, I posted. When I was sad, I posted. When Markos said something to me that was particularly cruel, I turned to Facebook. It became a haven.

And there was one man in particular that I looked forward talking to. He was sweet. He was funny. He liked to listen to me. He thought I was smart. We enjoyed the same things. He let me talk about my kids. I began anticipating notes from him. I was in a whirlwind that I thought I would never experience again — the giddy feeling of being in love. The thought of Markos seeing these interactions made me extremely nervous, so I started hiding my trail. I knew Markos could not access Facebook from work, even from our joint account. So I was able to spend my days having fun with my “friend,” as long as I was sure to delete all messages before Markos got home.

I justified this. Markos had told me that I should find someone else to talk to. So I did. He told me to do it. Right?

I began neglecting my kids. All I wanted was HIM. I was consumed. It felt so wonderful and special. I felt special again. I took my wedding ring off that Christmas, with the intent of never putting it back on.

He allured me, and spoke tenderly to meMeanwhile, Markos was trying to meet my emotional needs. He was still following the Marriage Builders program and he had taken an anger management class to learn to eliminate his anger. But nothing was working. He was spinning his wheels and didn’t know why — he didn’t know that I was in love with someone else.

I had no intention of ever telling him, either. I may have been drugged up on the allure of the other man (OM, as they are often called), but I was smart enough to know that Markos was the one providing the roof over my head and the food on my table. I saw this as a sweet arrangement: I would let Markos keep providing for my physical needs, and for the needs of my children, but that was it. I would go to OM for any other need I had.

Our messages turned to sexual flirting. I justified it even more: Markos had told me to find someone else. He was getting what he asked for. No wrong there. Right?

But guilt was beginning to build: Part of me knew there was no future with OM. I would look at my kids every morning, and start to cry. I knew I was hurting them. I didn’t care worth a flip about Markos, but I knew my kids were suffering because of me. But I continued to seek OM out. I could not seem to stop — and when I sat down at my computer, I had NO DESIRE to stop.

I once suggested that Markos turn to porn or visit a prostitute. This would only justify what I was doing myself. No one would blame me if they ever found out what he was doing. Right? He didn’t fall for that.

Markos still pursued me. That was getting to be pretty annoying. I just wanted to be left alone, to do my own thing, and not have the constant reminder that he was there.

Soon after, a friend emailed me. She had also been through Marriage Builders, and wanted to help me with my marriage. Over the course of a month, we talked and I ended up confessing to her what I was doing. She strongly encouraged me to talk to him myself. I spent several days tossing back and forth between confessing and not confessing. Of course, I did not want to talk to Markos: he was a monster. He would be cruel. I hated the thought of giving up OM for my dreadful husband. And I just knew he would probably toss me out. On the other hand, I knew if I didn’t tell him, SHE would. That’s what Marriage Builders people do.

I decided to text him. I figured if he blew up, I could load up the kids and leave before he got home. His first response crumbled my pride. Not because it was full of anger — no, it was surprisingly calm. But he knew the OM’s name. How could he know? I was so careful. I still don’t know how he knew, but he did. I wasn’t as clever as I thought I was. I felt so very small at that point. Naked.

That text was the first step on the real road to recovery for us. He didn’t blow up at me like I expected. He was eerily calm, and that, in its own way, unnerved me.

He didn’t expose me — He did ask me to write a letter to my family and to the elders in my church, confessing what I did . He insisted that I send the letter before a big family birthday party for my daughter. I wanted to wait, but he wanted everyone to know. I did it because I feared that he would divorce me and I would lose my kids, and yes, I was pretty angry about that. I hated him even more, and literally did not speak a word to him for quite some time.

I do not recommend anybody follow our lead in how that was handled — I guarantee you there would have been a lot less resentment and anger to get over if he had just exposed me rather than making me confess to my family. Exposure is therapeutic for the wayward.

After I sent the letter, he came into the room and found me curled up on the bed. He tenderly caressed the tears on my face and kissed me on the forehead. I shuddered. The monster was not being so monstrous, but rather gentle. And it wasn’t fair. I needed him to be hateful, so that I could believe I was really justified. He wasn’t playing his part right.

He took me and the kids to a picnic in the park the day after the birthday party and the letter, and I sat up at the car and sulked and cried while he played with the kids next to the lake.

The day I compared him to OM, and told him how much better OM treated me, he looked me straight in the eyes and said “I will not share you, not even emotionally.” Again, another shudder.

The typical wayward wife will be angry and unremorseful well into recovery. But recovery is still possible — that is, if all contact with OM is cut off. It took me awhile to cut off all contact. I blocked him on Facebook initially, but I was still going to Facebook. That pining for the OM was keeping me triggered, and keeping my lovebank closed to Markos. We eventually shutdown and blocked Facebook completely. This was vital to our recovery.

We adopted the Extraordinary Precautions found in Surviving an Affair on pages 66-67. These were also vital to our recovery. The thing about recovery from something as devastating to a marriage as an affair, the road is very narrow. Each step must be taken carefully, or you will stumble off the road and the marriage will lie in ruin.

I HATED my husband. I loathed him. I tried to trap him into being unfaithful himself. I blamed HIM for my Emotional Affair. He still won me. He relentlessly pursued me. He allured me, and spoke tenderly to me. He went through hell, and put up with all kinds of barbs and stab wounds from me, all to win ME. He saved me. He is my Hosea.

“I will restore to you the years the locusts have stolen …” Joel 2:25

Ask your counselor these questions

If you are seeing a marriage counselor, you might ask your counselor if he or she feels that these are reasonable goals for marriage:What To Ask Your Marriage Counselor

If your counselor doesn’t feel that these are reasonable goals, I would suggest that you discontinue working with that counselor.  The marriage recovery program I write about here achieves all of these goals.  Many counselors don’t believe that these things are possible, and I would avoid those counselors.

Many counselors will try to argue against these goals.  Some will tell you that the feeling of being in love fades after a few years and then you have to rely on commitment or hard work.  Some will tell you that expecting to stay in love for a lifetime is naive or immature.  Some counselors would tell you that realistically you have to expect that sometimes you will fight or have angry outbursts at each other.  And almost all counselors would say that you can’t make decisions that will make you both happy all the time and will encourage each of you to sacrifice sometimes and for there to be a lot of “give and take.”  Many of them would also tell you to not expect fulfillment from each other, but to try to learn to be happy from within or from some other source like your job or your religion or you relationship with God.

Some counselors will even try to use religion to back up their viewpoints.  They may say that expecting to stay in love for a lifetime is idolatry, or that you are supposed to get your needs met only by God, or that God wants you to sacrifice for your spouse instead of expecting each decision to be something you are both happy with, or that God did not create marriage to make you happy but instead wants to use it to make you a better person through suffering.  All of this completely contradicts the experience my wife and I have had: we followed this program, fell in love together again, don’t fight, and we get our fulfillment from our marriage.  It is true that we credit God with this – we view each other as a gift from God, and believe that God meets people’s needs through other people.

If you have tried to follow the program I am writing about and it doesn’t seem to be working for you, or one or both of you can’t seem to stick to the program consistently, I strongly encourage you to get help.

Don’t mix and match

Every week I hear of people trying to mix the marriage principles that I am writing about here with things they got from another marriage book or a marriage counselor.Don't Mix and Match: What NOT to do if you want to save your marriage

The difference between this plan and what you will get from other marriage advice sources is that this plan teaches couples how to fall in love with each other, and how to stay in love.  Almost all other counselors, books, and advisers believe that sustaining the feeling of love for a lifetime is impossible and unnecessary.  So instead of teaching you how to create or recreate the feeling of love, they try to persuade you to just tolerate a marriage without that feeling.

Most marriage counseling does not succeed.  That should make you very cautious when you read or listen to anything about marriage.

Many people spend a lot of time and money with a counselor learning communication skills or how to resolve conflicts or all of the standard stuff and still end up divorced or miserable because they are still not in love.If you want to mess up this plan, the best way to do it is to try mix and match with other marriage approaches.

I searched for the phrase “I love you but I’m not in love with you” on the web last week.  I found a blog post by a marriage advising institute I had not heard of.  It was a very long post, and it was dedicated to telling people that they were failing if they expected to stay in love for their whole marriage.  The author was in a near panic that if people believed the feeling of love could be sustained, that they would go out and have an affair to get that feeling.  The author believed that if people believe that the feeling of love should last for a lifetime, they will throw away their spouse and their children for it.

But falling in love is a well-understood process.  Create certain conditions, and the feeling of romantic love is created.  Do that with your spouse, and don’t do it with anybody else.  Falling in love with your spouse will not hurt your spouse or your children – in fact, it will benefit them.

Please don’t dabble with other counseling materials.  They don’t work because they aren’t even trying to work  – they don’t believe it’s possible to remain in love for a lifetime, and so they do not even try.  If you want to mess up this plan, the best way to do it is to try mix and match with other marriage approaches.

For the same reason, if your spouse won’t follow this plan, but is willing to see a counselor, I wouldn’t get too excited or too optimistic.  If you’re in that boat, send me an email, because I have some suggestions for you: MarkosOnMarriage@gmail.com  The last thing you want to do is go to a counselor who will try to tell your spouse they should just be content with what they have.

If you haven’t already, be sure to take a look at this article by Dr. Jennifer Chalmers: Romantic Love: Is it a Realistic Goal for Marital Therapy?